2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Results

2017 JUDICIAL EVALUATION SURVEY RESULTS

 A total of 388 surveys were emailed out to TCBA members and a total of 85 surveys were completed,

representing 21.9 percent of the TCBA membership. Responses were tabulated and an average rating for all respondents was calculated.  Only ratings between 1 and 5 were included; “Don’t Know” and items not rated were excluded when calculating the averages.  The averaged results in each category are listed below.

Superior Court Judge Anne Hirsch

Knowledge of Criminal law                               3.28

Knowledge of Civil law                                      3.25

Knowledge of Family law                                  3.84

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.54

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.54

Would Vote to Re-elect                                 65.6%

 

Superior Court Judge Carol Murphy

Knowledge of Criminal law                               3.28

Knowledge of Civil law                                      3.77

Knowledge of Family law                                  2.59

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.55

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.44

Would Vote to Re-elect                                    65%

 

Superior Court Judge Mary Sue Wilson

Knowledge of Criminal law                               3.40

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.00

Knowledge of Family law                                  2.60

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.95

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.86
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 91.1%

 

Superior Court Judge James Dixon

Knowledge of Criminal Law                             4.65

Knowledge of Civil Law                                     4.23

Knowledge of Family Law                                3.53

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.33

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.47
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 95.2%

 

Superior Court Judge Christine Schaller                 

Knowledge of Criminal law                               4.41

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.17

Knowledge of Family law                                  4.64

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.00

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.36
Would Vote to Re-elect                                    91%

 

Superior Court Judge Erik D. Price

Knowledge of Criminal law                               3.70

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.02

Knowledge of Family law                                  3.00

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.98

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.98
Would Vote to Re-elect                                    85%

 

Superior Court Judge John Skinder

Knowledge of Criminal law                               4.67

Knowledge of Civil law                                      3.47

Knowledge of Family law                                  2.67

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.66

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.96
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 95.5%

 

Superior Court  Judge Christopher Lanese

Knowledge of Criminal law                               2.46

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.27

Knowledge of Family law                                  2.27

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.29

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.09
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 81.6%

 

District Court Judge Brett Buckley

Knowledge of Criminal law                               4.53

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.42
Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.58

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.00
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 93.1%

 

District Court Judge Samuel G. Meyer

Knowledge of Criminal law                               4.38

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.24

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.23

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.24
Would Vote to Re-elect                                 96.3%

 

District Court Judge Kalo Wilcox               

Knowledge of Criminal law                               3.66

Knowledge of Civil law                                      3.68

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.25

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.27
Would Vote to Re-elect                                    80%

 

Commissioner Jonathon Lack

Knowledge of Family law                                  3.83

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.13

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.79
Support Continuing as Commissioner           74%

 

Commissioner Paul Wohl

Knowledge of Criminal law                               4.50

Knowledge of Civil law                                      4.31

Treats Participants Fairly                                   4.56

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 4.38
Support Continuing as Commissioner           95%

 

Commissioner Rebekah Zinn

Knowledge of Civil law                                      3.73

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.08

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.43
Support Continuing as Commissioner           78%

 

Commissioner Indu Thomas

Knowledge of Family Law                                3.61

Treats Participants Fairly                                   3.50

Makes Efficient Use of Court Time                 3.57

Support Continuing as Commissioner        65.4%

Heather Ligtenberg2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Results